medium · LSAT Reading Comprehension

In tort law, a plaintiff must establish not only that the defendant's conduct was a cause-in-fact of an injury but also that it was the 'proximate cause.' Cause-in-fact asks whether the harm would have occurred 'but for' the defendant's act. Proximate cause, by contrast, is a policy-driven limitation: even where an act sets a chain of events in motion, liability extends only to harms that were a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the conduct. When the connection between the act and the ultimate injury is so attenuated, or the intervening events so freakish, that no reasonable person would have anticipated them, courts hold that proximate cause is lacking and the defendant escapes liability. The doctrine thus prevents a negligent actor from being held responsible for every remote and bizarre outcome that can be traced, however indirectly, to the original act.

Based on the passage's logic, which of the following defendants would most likely escape liability due to a lack of proximate cause?

  1. A person leaves a small candle burning near a window; a bird flies into the window, shattering the glass, a shard of which severs a power line blocks away.
  2. A driver exceeds the speed limit and strikes a pedestrian who is crossing in a marked crosswalk.
  3. A restaurant server spills a glass of water, and a nearby patron slips and falls on the wet tile.
  4. A homeowner fails to salt an icy sidewalk, and a delivery person slips and breaks an arm walking to the door.
  5. A factory negligently stores flammable solvents, and a discarded cigarette ignites them, burning the adjacent warehouse.

Sign up free to see the explanation and track your rank →

More LSAT Reading Comprehension practice

KomFi Academy — Stop doomscrolling. Get KomFi.

Build your intelligence, anytime, anywhere.

KomFi Academy is a curated training platform with 46,000+ practice questions, 20,000+ flashcards, on-demand video lectures, podcasts, and 4K slide decks across the topics serious professionals study: GMAT, LSAT, MCAT, Investment Banking, Private Equity (LBOs & PE math), Private Credit, Quantitative Finance, Financial Accounting, Asset- Backed Securities, Volume Profile Analysis, Order Flow Trading, Market Microstructure, Volume Spread Analysis, Elliott Wave Theory, Volume-Price Analysis, and Public Offering Frameworks.

What's inside

Topics

View pricing · Read testimonials