medium · LSAT Reading Comprehension
Passage A: Proponents of restorative justice argue that the primary goal of the legal system should be to repair the harm caused by a crime rather than simply punishing the offender. By bringing victims and offenders together in a controlled environment, restorative justice fosters empathy and accountability, which statistically reduces recidivism. Traditional punitive measures often isolate offenders, further entrenching them in criminal subcultures.
Passage B: While the goals of restorative justice are noble, the implementation of such programs must not come at the expense of retributive justice. The legal system exists to uphold a moral order, and punishment serves as a necessary social expression of disapproval for wrongdoing. If a system focuses solely on reconciliation, it risks trivializing the gravity of the offense and undermining the deterrent effect that clear, consistent punishment provides.
Which one of the following best describes the point at issue between the authors of the two passages?
- Whether the legal system's central purpose should be mending the harm a crime causes or affirming a moral order through punishment.
- Whether restorative justice programs in practice produce a statistically meaningful and durable drop in offender recidivism rates.
- Whether the legal system ought to favor rehabilitating the convicted offender over directly serving the individual victim's stated needs.
- Whether punitive isolation is the one and only factor that ever drives convicted offenders deeper into entrenched criminal subcultures.
- Whether punishment, viewed purely as a social expression of disapproval, is morally legitimate under any conceivable circumstances at all.
Sign up free to see the explanation and track your rank →
More LSAT Reading Comprehension practice
- The author's use of the word "demonstrates" most strongly suggests that the author's attit
- Which one of the following most accurately describes the author's attitude toward true cri
- Which one of the following most accurately describes the author's attitude toward urban mi
- Which one of the following most accurately describes the author's attitude toward the pres
- Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?
- Which one of the following most accurately describes the primary purpose of the second par
- Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?
- Which one of the following most accurately describes the primary function of the second pa