hard · GMAT Verbal
Passage: The Miller-Urey experiment, conducted in 1952, attempted to simulate the conditions of the early Earth's atmosphere to test the feasibility of abiogenesis—the origin of life from non-living matter. By subjecting a mixture of water, methane, ammonia, and hydrogen to electrical sparks (representing lightning), the researchers were able to produce several amino acids, the building blocks of proteins. This result suggested that the complex organic molecules necessary for life could form spontaneously under prebiotic conditions. However, later geochemical evidence suggested that the early atmosphere was likely not as reducing as Miller and Urey assumed; instead of being rich in methane and ammonia, it may have been composed primarily of carbon dioxide and nitrogen. Experiments using this revised atmospheric composition have yielded fewer organic compounds, leading some scientists to look toward alternative environments, such as alkaline hydrothermal vents or comet impacts, as the potential sites for the synthesis of the first biomolecules.
Why have some scientists turned away from the Miller-Urey model of atmospheric synthesis?
- The amino acids produced in the experiment were found to be different from those used by modern biological organisms.
- New findings suggested that the gases used in the original experiment did not accurately reflect the Earth's early atmosphere.
- The synthesis of organic molecules was proven to be impossible in an atmosphere dominated by carbon dioxide.
- Electrical sparks were determined to be an insufficient energy source for the formation of complex proteins.
- Subsequent experiments proved that life actually originated in comet impacts rather than on the Earth's surface.
Sign up free to see the explanation and track your rank →
More GMAT Verbal practice
- What logical role do the first two statements play?
- Which of the following is the conclusion?
- A gardener says: 'All roses in this garden require daily wat… — What is the role of the st
- What is the conclusion?
- What is the conclusion?
- Which statement is the conclusion?
- What is the conclusion?
- What logical role does the first sentence play in the researcher's argument?