KomFi. Academy

medium · LSAT Logical Reasoning

A sign reads: only members can enter the lounge. David entered the lounge.

Is the conclusion that David is a member valid?

  1. No, because the inference affirms the consequent by reading the lounge entry rule backward here.
  2. Yes, because entering the lounge requires the very status of membership the sign makes a precondition.
  3. Yes, because it is a valid modus tollens that denies the consequent to reach the membership conclusion.
  4. No, because the inference denies the antecedent by starting from David's supposed lack of membership.
  5. Yes, but only on the further assumption that the lounge's membership rolls are perfectly enforced daily.

Sign up free to see the explanation and track your rank →

More LSAT Logical Reasoning practice

All Logical Reasoning questions · LSAT study guide · LSAT glossary · LSAT flashcards