KomFi. Academy

easy · LSAT Logical Reasoning

The film critic's claim that the director's latest movie is a masterpiece is clearly mistaken. The critic is a close personal friend of the director and has repeatedly praised the director's earlier, decidedly mediocre films.

The argument is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that it:

  1. dismisses a claim purely by impugning the impartiality of the person who advanced it
  2. draws an analogy between two art forms that are not relevantly similar
  3. assumes that a person's past judgments must always match their present ones
  4. neglects to specify what features a film must have to count as a masterpiece
  5. treats one critic's praise of mediocre films as proof that all critics are unreliable

Sign up free to see the explanation and track your rank →

More LSAT Logical Reasoning practice

All Logical Reasoning questions · LSAT study guide · LSAT glossary · LSAT flashcards