KomFi. Academy

easy · LSAT Logical Reasoning

A critic of a new education policy argues: Professor Williams, a world-renowned expert on eighteenth-century poetry, has publicly criticized the new mathematics curriculum. Therefore we should reconsider that curriculum.

The critic's argument is most vulnerable to criticism on the ground that it:

  1. rests on the opinion of an authority whose field of expertise has no bearing on the matter being decided.
  2. assumes that Professor Williams's command of poetry makes him incapable of grasping any mathematics whatever.
  3. neglects to set out the specific reasons for which Professor Williams objects to the new curriculum.
  4. takes for granted that the existing mathematics curriculum it would replace has performed entirely well.
  5. presumes that any curriculum even a single qualified critic opposes ought for that reason to be scrapped.

Sign up free to see the explanation and track your rank →

More LSAT Logical Reasoning practice

All Logical Reasoning questions · LSAT study guide · LSAT glossary · LSAT flashcards