medium · LSAT Logical Reasoning

Which one of the following judgments conforms most closely to the principle above?

1. A scholar with two published books is refused tenure because their classroom evaluations dipped to merely average in their third year.
2. Any teacher with five straight years of strong evaluation scores plus one book is automatically entitled to be granted tenure.
3. A researcher who has published three scholarly books is awarded tenure chiefly because that work brought the university wide fame.
4. The university grants tenure to a popular, beloved teacher who has published only a handful of short articles in major academic journals.
5. A professor holding a peer-reviewed book and five straight years of consistently outstanding evaluations is nonetheless denied tenure by the panel.

Sign up free to see the explanation and track your rank →