medium · MCAT cars
Passage: Meritocracy—the idea that social and economic rewards should be distributed based on individual talent and effort—is a seductive social ideal. It promises a 'level playing field' where the accident of birth is replaced by the rigor of achievement. However, critics argue that meritocracy often serves to legitimize existing inequalities. If success is seen as a sign of merit, then failure is seen as a sign of personal deficiency, ignoring the structural advantages (wealth, social capital, elite education) that 'merit' often hides. In a truly unequal society, a meritocracy becomes a 'hereditary' one, where the winners of the previous generation ensure their children have the resources to become the 'meritorious' of the next. Thus, meritocracy can become a tool of social closure, providing a thin veneer of fairness to a system that remains deeply entrenched in class-based privilege.
How would a proponent of meritocracy most likely respond to the author's claim that meritocracy 'legitimizes existing inequalities'?
- By claiming that even if structures are unequal, individuals from impoverished backgrounds can still succeed through exceptional grit and talent.
- By suggesting that elite education and inherited private wealth be abolished entirely, ensuring that wealth alone cannot purchase merit.
- By arguing that any large-scale social system will inevitably become somewhat unequal over time, so meritocracy is the least unfair option available.
- By asserting that personal deficiency, rather than structural disadvantage, is the primary cause of most social and economic failure today.
Sign up free to see the explanation and track your rank →
More MCAT cars practice
- Which of the following best identifies the conclusion of this argument?
- If the negation of the statement logically undermines the author's conclusion, what does t
- Which statement accurately describes the statistical interpretation of this finding if the
- An author argues that 'modern education systems fail because they prioritize rote memoriza
- What can the scientist conclude about the relationship between these variables?
- An isotope used in medical imaging has a half-life of 6 hour… — If a patient is injected w
- However, when the data from both clinics are combined, Drug B appears to have a higher ove
- Which of the following is the most accurate interpretation of this p-value?