medium · MCAT cars

Passage: John Austin’s 'command theory' of law represents a foundational, if somewhat rigid, pillar of legal positivism. Austin defined law as the command of a sovereign—a person or body whom the bulk of a society habitually obeys and who does not habitually obey any other human superior—backed by the threat of a sanction. In this view, the 'authority' of law is reduced to the empirical facts of power and obedience. There is no mystical 'obligation' to obey beyond the fear of punishment or the habit of compliance. Critics argue this fails to distinguish between a tax collector and a gunman; both demand money backed by a threat. However, Austin’s proponents suggest his model accurately reflects the 'unvarnished reality' of the state’s coercive nature, stripping away the romanticism that often obscures the functional mechanics of political control.

If it were discovered that a society obeyed a set of rules primarily due to a shared sense of moral duty rather than fear of a sovereign's punishment, how would this affect Austin's command theory?

  1. It would strengthen the theory by proving that the sovereign has successfully educated the public.
  2. It would weaken the theory by suggesting that sanctions are not the primary driver of legal order.
  3. It would have no effect because moral duty is outside the scope of 'is' in legal analysis.
  4. It would prove that the sovereign is actually a divine entity rather than a human one.

Sign up free to see the explanation and track your rank →

More MCAT cars practice

KomFi: Test Prep Made Easy

KomFi: Test Prep Made Easy — free adaptive practice for GMAT, GRE, SAT, ACT, National Real Estate Exam, Investment Banking, and finance with full explanations.

KomFi Academy is free GMAT prep and personalized GMAT help built as a training platform: 75,000+ practice questions, 26,500+ flashcards, on-demand video lectures, podcasts, and 4K slide decks. Flagship tracks: Free GMAT Prep, Free GMAT Resources, National Real Estate Exam Prep, Investment Banking Prep, Finance Prep, GRE, SAT, ACT, LSAT, MCAT, Financial Accounting, Private Equity, Private Credit, and Quantitative Finance.

Free GMAT Prep & Personalized GMAT Help

What's inside

Topics

View pricing · Read testimonials