medium · MCAT cars
Passage: Judicial restraint is an interpretive philosophy that urges judges to refrain from overturning laws unless they are clearly unconstitutional. It is rooted in the belief that in a democracy, policy-making should be left to the accountable branches—the legislature and the executive. Proponents argue that when judges strike down laws based on their own moral or political judgments, they diminish the prestige of the judiciary and undermine the democratic process. They suggest that the Court should defer to legislative judgments on 'debatable' questions of social policy. Critics, on the other hand, argue that judicial restraint often amounts to judicial abdication. They contend that the Court's primary duty is to protect the Constitution and that 'restraint' in the face of constitutional violations is a failure of that duty. This debate reflects a fundamental disagreement over whether the judiciary's primary role is to respect democratic outcomes or to enforce constitutional limits.
Which of the following scenarios best illustrates the 'judicial abdication' described by critics?
- A court refusing to invalidate a law that likely violates a minority group's rights because the law is popular.
- A legislature promptly repealing an unpopular statute soon after a court declared it unconstitutional.
- A judge overturning a long-standing precedent in order to substantially expand the scope of individual liberty.
- The President himself publicly and repeatedly refusing to enforce a judicial ruling that invalidates an executive order.
Sign up free to see the explanation and track your rank →
More MCAT cars practice
- Which of the following best identifies the conclusion of this argument?
- If the negation of the statement logically undermines the author's conclusion, what does t
- An author argues that 'modern education systems fail because they prioritize rote memoriza
- What can the scientist conclude about the relationship between these variables?
- Which statement accurately describes the statistical interpretation of this finding if the
- Which of the following is the most accurate interpretation of this finding?
- However, when the data from both clinics are combined, Drug B appears to have a higher ove
- Which of the following, if true, would most weaken the author's argument?